Tuesday, October 13, 2009

Who Would You Rather Have: Derek Jeter or Jose Reyes

Who Would You Rather Have: Derek Jeter or Troy Tulowitzki? - FakeTeams

I'd take Tulowitzki over Jeter. But I am wondering about when to take the plunge on Reyes. Isn't Jeter a safer pick?

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Ray here-yes, Jeter is safer than Reyes imo. And yes, I take Tulo, who I was wrong about coming into the '09 season.

IMHO said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
IMHO said...

As long as there isn't a permanent loss of speed from Reyes, I think he can match Jeter's SB in a partial season. The question are the other counting stats.

With the new Yankees Stadium perfectly matched to Jeter's power and Citifield still percevied as a HR killer, I think Jeter would outproduce across the other four cats even if Reyes played a full season. They'd be close in Runs and RBI though.