By HRs in 2009, Derek Jeter is the top AL-Only SS. Thrown-in 30 SBs and an AVG over .300, and Jeter easily becomes the top SS in AL-only formats. The question that needs to be answered is whether the 35-year-old can repeat his 2009 performance in 2010.
FWIW, Jeter finished 4th overall amongst SS qualifiers in HRs according to ESPN. Hell, Ronny Cedeno's 10 HRs ranks him 12th!
SS is a shallow position with little breakout potential after Stephen Drew.