The guys at Razzball have ranked Matt Weiters as the 3rd best catcher going into 2012. And Victor Martinez's injury did not provide a bump up the ranks. VMart was 6th pre-ACL injury.
Since I have had Weiters on my AL-only team for as long as he has been available in my drafts, this ranking is the kind of information I want. It confirms everything I want to be true!
Top 20 Catchers for 2012 Fantasy Baseball